Structured Settlements 4Real®Blog 2026

Structured settlements expert John Darer reviews the latest structured settlements and settlement planning information and news, and provides expert opinion and highly regarded commentary. that is spicy, Informative, irreverent and effective for over 20 years.

Annuity.org Revived Tired “Bobby Bonilla Day” for the Ides of March. Why?

by Structured Settlement Watchdog

Annuity.org could not wait until July 1st to revive the tired “Bobby Bonilla Day” story so they revived it for the “Ides of March” Hold the Caesar Salad!

Business must be slow

Annuity.org’s 35-year-old research challenged staff writer Catherine Byerly, who was only 12 years old in July 1999, gossiped about Bonilla “getting into shouting matches with team manager Bobby Valentine wasn’t exactly helping team moral (sic). (There were even allegations, later denied, that Bonilla threatened to fight Valentine after a heated exchange in the dugout)”, snipped Byerlye. 

  • Ken Griffey, Jr.  $112M contract deferred $3.59MM/year from 2009-2024. Despite being retired and not playing for the Reds since 2008, Hall of Fame slugger Ken Griffey Jr. is the 6th highest-paid players on the Cincinnati Reds.  Multiple Sources.
  • Manny Ramirez  $160M contract deferred $1.968MM/year from  2011-2026
  • Matt Holliday     $120M contract deferred $1.5MM/year from 2020-2029
  • Bruce Sutter      $4.8MM contract deferred $1.12MM/year from 1991-2022

Performance comparisons

Griffey Jr.  630 HR,  .284 BA,  1836 RBI,  184 SB, .538 SLG

Ramirez     535 HR   .312 BA,  1831 RBI   38 SB,   .585 SLG

Holliday     316 HR   .299 BA    1220 RBI   108 SB   .510 SLG

Bonilla       287 HR   .287 BA    1173  RBI   48 SB     .472 SLG

Bobby Bonilla career stats were well below his peers with deferred payment agreements

But for the fact the Mets and others were scammed by the late crooked Bernie Madoff, there would be no Bobby Bonilla Day.  Instead of “celebrating” Bonilla, consider Bonilla’s deferred compensation peers as a better role model for annuities. Madoff was a crook who destroyed lives and died a miserable death at FMC Butner. 

Annuity.org Showcases its Lack of Class by proliferating the Bernie Madoff angle to the Bonilla Story with its title “Commonalities of Bernie Madoff, Baseball and Annuities”

  • According to the New York Department of Financial Services, “an annuity is a contract issued by an insurance company. 
  • An annuity is a contract between a purchaser and an insurance company in which the purchaser agrees to make a lump sum payment or series of payments in return for regular disbursements, beginning either immediately (within 12 months) or at some future date”.
  • If the deferred payments to Bonilla were simply a contract signed by Bonilla and the Mets, and the Mets were self-insuring, relying on the assumptions of investments made with Bernard L. Madoff, it doesn’t fall within that definition.
Meme featuring a man with gray hair and a serious expression, overlaid with text discussing bad examples in financial decisions, referencing Bobby Bonilla's deferred payment agreement.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Posted in , , , , , ,

Discover more from Structured Settlements 4Real®Blog 2026

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading